Leeds children’s heart surgery – anyone for a game of Chinese whispers?

_home_panew_uk_news 5-1As if the situation weren’t complicated enough, we’ve just had a depressing game of Chinese whispers going on in the media about a possible re-start of child heart surgery at the LGI.

It all started yesterday (Sunday) at 5pm when ITV’s regional news outfit Calendar ran a story saying:

The body running the NHS in England says it hopes that Leeds General infirmary will “shortly be in a position to restart children’s heart surgery secure in the knowledge that everything is okay.”

The report went on to quote a statement from an NHS England spokesperson as saying (bits in bold from me):

“Most of the big failures in NHS care have featured arguments about data. It is just days after the government’s response to the Mid Staffs inquiry where people hesitated for exactly this reason and people suffered…It must be right to put the safety of children first. It was therefore a highly responsible step to suspend the service. We hope that Leeds will shortly be in a position to restart children’s heart surgery secure in the knowledge that everything is okay.”

The Calendar report wasn’t wrong. It’s just that the statement was old.

Hope? Make that ‘likely’ … Likely? Make that “WILL”

twitter first itv pickupIt didn’t take long for the report to be picked up on Twitter.

“Great news from NHS England that surgery is likely to re-start at LGI shortly,” said one tweet.

The statement didn’t say that, of course.

Chinese whisper number one.

twitter mulholland firstA whisper that was passed on to campaigning tweeter and local MP Greg Mulholland.

Now, guys, what do you do with Chinese whispers? You compound the initial mistake, add another one and pass it on!

So we get Chinese whispers numbers two and three from Mr Mulholland:

“Great news … that #childrensheartsurgery in #leeds will soon be restarted

… followed by …

“Confirmation from #NHS England that #Leeds children’s heart unit was safe ALL ALONG ‘secure in the knowledge that everything is OK'”

See what he did there, kids? No? Go back up to the original statement and look again.

Lone Twitter voice

tubbAs the congratulatory and celebratory tweets poured in, a lone voice (isn’t that the way with Twitter?) suggested to Mr Mulholland that he look again at the NHS statement.

The key quote was no different from what NHS England medical director Sir Bruce Keogh had said on Thursday, Sky news correspondent Gerard Tubb reminded the MP.

Here’s what Keogh had said:

“I hope that Leeds will shortly be in a position to restart children’s heart surgery secure in the knowledge that everything is okay”

Recognise the similarities? Swap “I” for “We” and they’re identical.

As far as I’m aware, the Lib-Dem politician hasn’t acknowledged that he got it wrong.

Hey! It’s only Twitter!

Whisper, whisper

telegraphSo, come today (Monday), and the Daily Telegraph are looking to freshen up their story.

Whisper, whisper …

Here comes whisper number four.

Under the headline “Hope that Leeds heart unit will re-open soon”, Science correspondent Nick Collins manages to tie an old NHS statement (masquerading as a new statement) to tomorrow’s talks at the hospital.

“The body that oversees the NHS England has said it hopes to restart heart surgery at Leeds General Infirmary soon, ahead of talks with doctors on Tuesday.”

Now, I’m sorry, but doesn’t that make it sound as though NHS England had made the statement ahead of (i.e. because of) the talks?

Which The Telegraph would’ve known wasn’t true. If they’d checked.

Out! Out! Out!

Sir Bruce Keogh

Sir Bruce Keogh

And if the bank holiday Sunday shift at Calendar had bothered to read the Yorkshire Post, they’d have found their “new” statement in its entirety, published 40 hours previously.

Ditto the bank holiday shift at the Telegraph, who’d have found that their key quotes were well over two days old.

Still, not to worry. The story has now moved on. Today (Monday) there’s a different “news” peg for Twitter to bray itself hoarse about.

Out! Out! Out!

What with whispers and distortions, depressingly partisan press coverage and know-all politicians permanently on their high horses, the whole sorry saga is starting to become pretty unedifying.

“It is really important that this review is carried out in a sensible, effective and decisive way,” said the NHS. “For that to happen it needs to follow a proper and complete process. It cannot be conducted in the media.”

Fat chance.

Advertisements

About the leeds citizen

contributions to this blog welcome
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Leeds children’s heart surgery – anyone for a game of Chinese whispers?

  1. Mike Chitty says:

    The pursuit of votes often trumps the pursuit of truth…

  2. Pingback: Leeds today: heart unit, easter hols, NAP, kirkgate, Leeds United, Gemmas, Reetsweet, art and Scouts. | Beyond Guardian Leeds

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s